The little blue box may be the standard for some, but Studio174 has a personal feel. You work with owners Caroline Glemann and Michael Fitzgerald from start to finish on your dream ring: Choose from silver, gold, or platinum, or one of their pared-down modern bands ($300 to $5,000).

Caroline's custom designed Platinum & Diamonds pendant and ring were chosen for this Best of New York Magazine's "Best Engagement Ring" article.